Błąd co do wierności małżeńskiej w kontekście jej wykluczenia

Grzegorz Leszczyński

doi:10.21697/im.2023.34.1.04

Published: 2023-06-28

Vol. 34 No. 1 (2023)

Error about marriage fidelity in the context of her exclusion

Grzegorz Leszczyński

Ius Matrimoniale

Section: Rozprawy i artykuły

https://doi.org/10.21697/im.2023.34.1.04

Abstract

Just as an error can determine the will not to accept marriage in accordance with the teaching of the Church, causing a defect in the consensus, so as well can marital fidelity be excluded directly by a positive act of will. The very phenomenon of error is part of the phenomenon of simulation, since in both cases there is a discrepancy between the will and its external form of expression. This does not mean, however, that the error determining the will is indistinguishable from a simulation. In the case of a simulation, there is a positive exclusion of the good of fidelity, in the case of an error, this exclusion is unconscious, i.e. without the participation of a positive act of will of the person. In this case, this positive act of will would be directed against a reality that one does not know.

Keywords: error, exclusion of fidelity, marriage, nullity

Keywords:

error, exclusion of fidelity, marriage, nullity

Download files

pdf (Język Polski)

Citation rules

Leszczyński, G. (2023). Error about marriage fidelity in the context of her exclusion. Ius Matrimoniale, 34(1), 83–96. https://doi.org/10.21697/im.2023.34.1.04

Cited by / Share

References

Źródła
Google Scholar

Dec. c. Colagiovanni z 18.03.1983 r., RRD 75 (1983), s. 118-128. Dec. c. Colagiovanni z 16.10.1991 r., RRD 83 (1991), s. 534-545. Dec. c. Defilippi z 27.07.1994 r., RRD 86 (1994), s. 411-435. Dec. c. De Jorio z 27.10.1971 r., RRD 63 (1971), s. 796-812.
Google Scholar

Dec. c. De Laversin z 26.01.1994 r., RRD 86 (1994), s. 47-55. Dec. c. Ewers z 19.05.1979 r., RRD 71 (1979), s. 284-294.
Google Scholar

Dec. c. Felici z 13.06.1954 r., RRD 46 (1954), s. 614-622. DOI: https://doi.org/10.25291/VR/1954-VLR-614
Google Scholar

Dec. c. Funghini z 14.05.1995 r., RRD 87 (1995), s. 311-337. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/0039-6028(95)92490-6
Google Scholar

Dec. c. Giannecchini z 19.11.1982 r., RRD 74 (1982), s. 537-547. Dec c. Giannecchini z 28.03.1995 r., RRD 87 (1995), s. 240-251. Dec. c. Màsala z 10.10.1973 r., RRD 65 (1973), s. 626-633.
Google Scholar

Dec. c. Palazzini z 8.10.1975 r., RRD 67 (1975), s. 540-549. Dec. c. Parisella z 15.10.1981 r., RRD 73 (1981), s. 488-497. Dec. c. Pinto z 6.11.1972 r., RRD 64 (1972), s. 672-680.
Google Scholar

Dec. c. Pompedda z 16.02.1972 r., RRD 64 (1972), s. 100-105. Dec. c. Pompedda z 26.11.1993 r., RRD 85 (1993), s. 715-722. Dec. c. Pozzi z 13.05.1972 r., RRD 64 (1972), s. 284-293.
Google Scholar

Dec. c. Ragni z 9.12.1982 r., RRD 74 (1982), s. 592-605. DOI: https://doi.org/10.2307/3792746
Google Scholar

Dec. c. Serrano z 22.03.1996 r., RRD 88 (1996), s. 309-314. Dec. c. Stankiewicz z 21.04.1983 r., RRD 75 (1983), s. 177-186. Dec. c. Stankiewicz z 14.11.1985 r., RRD 85 (1985), s. 485-494. Dec. c. Turnaturi z 18.04.1996 r., RRD 88 (1996), s. 334-348.
Google Scholar

Literatura
Google Scholar

Bianchi P., Quando il matrimonio è nullo?, Milano 1998.
Google Scholar

Bonnet P.A., Introduzione al consenso matrimoniale canonico, Milano 1985. Castaño J.F., Il Sacramento del matrimonio, Roma 1992.
Google Scholar

De Paolis V., L’errore che determina la volontà (cf . can . 1099), Monitor Ecclesiasticus
Google Scholar

(1995), s. 69-98.
Google Scholar

Grocholewski Z., L’errore circa l’unità, indissolubilità e la sacramentalità del
Google Scholar

matrimonio, w: P.A. Bonnet , C. Gullo (red.), Errore determinas voluntatem,
Google Scholar

Città del Vaticano 1995, s. 7-21.
Google Scholar

Grocholewski Z., Positivo atto di volontà come causa di nullità del matrimonio
Google Scholar

secondo il can . 1101 par . 2 del nuovo Codice, w: Questioni canoniche, Milano
Google Scholar

, s. 251-270.
Google Scholar

Kowal J., L’errore circa le proprietà essenziali o la dignità sacramentale del matri-
Google Scholar

monio (can . 1099), Periodica 87 (1998), s. 287-327. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/j.2168-9830.1998.tb00361.x
Google Scholar

Leszczyński G., Denegatio iuris w świetle wykluczenia dobra wierności małżeń-
Google Scholar

skiej, Prawo Kanoniczne 62 (2019) nr 3, s. 89-104.
Google Scholar

Leszczyński G., Exclusio boni fidei jako symulacja zgody małżeńskiej, Łódź 2004. Martín De Agar J.T., El error sobre la propiedades esenciales del matrimonio, Ius
Google Scholar

Canonicum 33 (1995), s. 117-141.
Google Scholar

Stankiewicz A., Błąd co do istotnych przymiotów i sakramentalności małżeństwa,
Google Scholar

Prawo Kanoniczne 28 (1985), s. 17-31. DOI: https://doi.org/10.21697/pk.1985.28.3-4.02
Google Scholar

Stankiewicz A., De iurisprudentia rotali recentiore circa simulationem totalem et
Google Scholar

partialem (cc . 1101, § 2 CIC; 824, § 2 CCEO), Monitor Ecclesiasticus 72 (1997),
Google Scholar

s. 425-512.
Google Scholar

Viladrich P.J, Konsens małżeński . Sposoby prawnej oceny i interpretacji w kano-
Google Scholar

nicznych procesach o stwierdzenie nieważności małżeństwa, Warszawa 2000.
Google Scholar