Symulacja całkowita i wykluczenie dóbr małżeństwa w świetle wyroku Roty Rzymskiej coram Bottone z 8 marca 2012 roku

Adam Młynarczyk

doi:10.21697/im.2023.35.2.08

Published: 2024-12-12

Vol. 35 No. 2 (2024)

Total simulation and exclusion of Goods of Marriage in the sentence of the Roman Rota c. Bottone of 8 March 2012

Adam Młynarczyk

Ius Matrimoniale

Section: Orzecznictwo sądowe

https://doi.org/10.21697/im.2023.35.2.08

Abstract

This article is a commentary on the Roman Rota sentence coram Bottone of 8th march 2012. The case concerned total simulation of marital consent and exclusion of good of offspring, faith as well as a sacrament and in the Roman Rota was examined in the third instance. Interesting element of the sentence is that in each of the three instances the verdict was affirmative, but in each case was declared on a different reason (In the first one, its nullity was based on the total simulation established on behalf of a petitioner. In the second one – it was an exclusion of good of faith by the petitioner. In the Roman Rota the positive verdict was based on a proof of the exclusion of good of faith and sacrament also by the petitioner). The analysis of the sentence is the example of a reliable and accurate evaluation of evidence collected in this case.

Keywords:

nullity of marriage, partial simulation of marital consent, Roman Rota, total simulation of marital consent

Download files

pdf (Język Polski)

Citation rules

Młynarczyk, A. (2024). Total simulation and exclusion of Goods of Marriage in the sentence of the Roman Rota c. Bottone of 8 March 2012. Ius Matrimoniale, 35(2), 175–189. https://doi.org/10.21697/im.2023.35.2.08

Cited by / Share

References

Źródła:
Google Scholar

Dec. c. BOTTONE, 08.03.2012, RRD 104 (2012), s. 42-48.
Google Scholar

CONGREGATIO PRO DOCTRINA FIDEI, Instructio de observantia erga vitam humanam nascentem deque procreationis dignitate tuenda Donum vitae, 22.02.1987, AAS 80 (1988), s. 70-102.
Google Scholar

Opracowania:
Google Scholar

ANDRIANO V., La normativa canonica sul matrimonio e la riforma del suo processo, Città del Vaticano 2016.
Google Scholar

CABERLETTI G., Il tribunale della Rota Romana: procedure e giurisprudenza, Quaderni di diritto ecclesiale, 24 (2011), s. 473-499.
Google Scholar

KOŁBUC M., Zakaz zawarcia małżeństwa w Kodeksie Prawa Kanonicznego z 1983 r. i Instrukcji procesowej Dignitas connubii, Kościół i Prawo 1 (14) 2012, s. 179-194.
Google Scholar

LESZCZYŃSKI G., Causa simulandi a wykluczenie dobra wierności małżeńskiej, Ius Matrimoniale 32 (2021) nr 2, s. 5-20.
Google Scholar

SOBAŃSKI R., Orzekanie nieważności małżeństwa z dwu (lub więcej) tytułów wadliwego konsensu, Ius Matrimoniale 5 (11) 2000, s. 139-150.
Google Scholar

VILADRICH P.J., Konsens małżeński. Sposoby prawnej oceny i interpretacji w kanonicznych procesach o stwierdzenie nieważności małżeństwa (kanony 1095-1107 Kodeksu Prawa Kanonicznego), Warszawa 2002.
Google Scholar