La conciliazione nelle controversie amministrative durante la revisione del Codice di Diritto Canonico. Analisi dell’iter legislativo del can. 1733

Zbigniew Jałbrzykowski

doi:10.21697/pk.2018.61.2.06

Published: 2018-06-09

Vol. 61 No. 2 (2018)

Conciliation in the administrative recourses during Revision of the Code of Canon Law. Analysis of the legislative works on the can. 1733

Zbigniew Jałbrzykowski

Prawo Kanoniczne

Section: Rozprawy i Artykuły

https://doi.org/10.21697/pk.2018.61.2.06

Abstract

The article deals with the history of redaction of the can. 1733 of the Code of Canon Law, which has introduced into the ecclesiastical legal order the institution of conciliation/mediation in hierarchical recourses. The norm attires attention because of its relatively innovative character in the catholic Church law. It makes part of a group of canons of the Latin Code that exhort to solve legal controversies in a non-contentious way or «pacifice» or through an «aequa solutio». The newness of the conciliation in the ecclesiastical context hasn’t contribute to its success, it is relatively hardly known and applied in the resolution of administrative controversies. The main point is that the new institution has been poorly harmonized within the procedural context of the hierarchical recourse. From the acts of the Pontifical Commission for the Revision of the Code of Canon Law follows that the conciliation in hierarchical recourses wasn’t made subject of an orderly and profound reflection during the legislation process. At the beginning it hadn’t even appear to the legislators as a possible procedural alternative to the regular administrative recourse. Next, borrowed from the report On due process, a document approved by the U.S. Conference of Bishops, the conciliation was incorporated into the system of ecclesiastical administrative justice among some doubts and unsure ideas about its purpose and systemic position, as it seems from the legislative documentation. With the expulsion of the administrative tribunals in limine promulgationis its function and mode of implementation has become even more obscure. As a result, a fruit of uncertainty and uncoordinated amendments in the legislation process, the conciliation recommended by the can. 1733 is made an institution to the greatest extent inoperative.

Keywords:

Conciliation, mediation, hierarchical recourse, administrative procedure

Download files

PDF (Język Polski)

Citation rules

Jałbrzykowski, Z. (2018). Conciliation in the administrative recourses during Revision of the Code of Canon Law. Analysis of the legislative works on the can. 1733. Prawo Kanoniczne, 61(2). https://doi.org/10.21697/pk.2018.61.2.06

Cited by / Share

References

Bibliografia
Google Scholar

Źródła
Google Scholar

CANON LAW SOCIETY OF AMERICA, Protection of Rights of Persons in the Church: Revised Report of the Canon Law Society of America on the Subject of Due Process, Washington, D.C. 1991.
Google Scholar

Communicationes 39 (2007), p. 294-295.
Google Scholar

Communicationes 4 (1972), p. 35.
Google Scholar

Communicationes 42 (2010), p. 389-395.
Google Scholar

Communicationes 42 (2010), p. 403-411.
Google Scholar

Communicationes 42 (2010), p. 425-427.
Google Scholar

Communicationes 42 (2010), p. 70-73.
Google Scholar

Communicationes 42 (2010), p. 81.
Google Scholar

Communicationes 42 (2010), p. 96-102.
Google Scholar

Communicationes 43 (2011), p. 213.
Google Scholar

Communicationes 43 (2011), p. 229.
Google Scholar

Communicationes 43 (2011), p. 236.
Google Scholar

Communicationes 43 (2011), p. 239-256.
Google Scholar

New Commentary on the Code of Canon Law, ed. J.A. Beal, J.A. Coriden, T.J. Green, New York – Mahwah 2000.
Google Scholar

Nota sulla corrispondenza tra la Segreteria di Stato e la Pontificia Commissione per la Revisione del C.D.C. circa la promulgazione del Motu proprio, in: Communicationes 43 (2011), p. 439-440.
Google Scholar

PONTIFICIA COMMISSIO CODICI IURIS CANONICI RECOGNOSCENDO, Principia quae Codicis Iuris Canonici recognitionem dirigant a Pontificia Commissione proposita et Primi Generalis Coetus «Synodi Episcoporum» examini subiecta, Città del Vaticano 1967, p. 14.
Google Scholar

PONTIFICIA COMMISSIO CODICI IURIS CANONICI RECOGNOSCENDO, Relatio complectens synthesim animadversionum ab Em.mis atque Exc.mis Patribus Commissionis ad novissimum schema Codicis Iuris Canonici exhibitarum, cum responsionibus a secretaria et consultoribus datis, Città del Vaticano 1981, p. 339-340.
Google Scholar

PONTIFICIA COMMISSIO CODICI IURIS CANONICI RECOGNOSCENDO, Schema canonum de procedura administrativa, Città del Vaticano 1972, p. 6.
Google Scholar

Presidente della Pontificia Commissione per la Revisione del C.D.C. alla Segreteria di Stato del 30 novembre 1971, in: Communicationes 42 (2010), p. 389.
Google Scholar

Literatura
Google Scholar

BEAL J.P., Protecting the Rights of Lay Catholics, The Jurist 47 (1987), p. 149-151.
Google Scholar

BERNARDINI E., Commento allo schema “De procedura administrativa”, Apollinaris 45 (1972), p. 130.
Google Scholar

BUZZARD L.R., ECK L., Tell it to the Church. A biblical approach to resolving conflict out of court, Wheaton 1985.
Google Scholar

CORIDEN J.A., Alternative Dispute Resolution in the Church, CLSA Proceedings 48 (1986), p. 64.
Google Scholar

CORSO J., I modi per evitare il giudizio amministrativo, in: La giustizia amministrativa nella Chiesa, ed. Arcisodalizio della Curia Romana, Studi giuridici, vol. 24, Città del Vaticano 1991, 40.
Google Scholar

GHERRI P., Decidere e giudicare nella Chiesa, in: Decidere e giudicare nella Chiesa: atti della VI Giornata canonistica interdisciplinare, ed. P. Gherri, Città del Vaticano 2012, p. 50-51.
Google Scholar

KRUKOWSKI J., Środki pojednawcze zmierzające do zapobieżenia powstaniu sporu administracyjnego, Rocznik Nauk Prawnych 21 (2011), p. 175.
Google Scholar

MARTENS K., Protection of Rights: Experiences with Hierarchical Recourse and Possibilities for the Future, The Jurist 69 (2009), 687.
Google Scholar

Mediacje. Teoria i praktyka, ed. E. Gmurzyńska, R. Morek, Warszawa 2014, p. 23-24.
Google Scholar

MOLLOY T. E., The Theological Foundation of Ecclesiastical Due Process, CLSA Proceedings 41 (1979), p. 152-153.
Google Scholar

MONTINI G.P., De recursibus hierarchicis, Romae 2016.
Google Scholar

ROMANKO A., Mediacja w sprawach administracyjnych w prawie kanonicznym i w prawie polskim [La mediazione nelle cause amministrative nel diritto canonico e nel diritto statale polacco], Lublin 2016.
Google Scholar

ROSEMAN D., Mediation in the Church. A Review of the Literature and of the Key Elements of Mediation, Studia canonica 47 (2013), p. 166-167.
Google Scholar

VERMEERSCH A., CREUSEN J., Epitome iuris canonici: cum commentariis ad scholas et ad usum privatum, vol. III, Mechliniae – Romae 1927.
Google Scholar