Brak wystarczającego używania rozumu (kan. 1095 n. 1 KPK), poważny brak rozeznania oceniającego (kan. 1095 n. 2 KPK), przymus lub bojaźń (kan. 1103 KPK), symulacja zgody małżeńskiej (kan. 1101 §2 KPK) po stronie mężczyzny w sprawie (rozpoznanej z powództw

Wojciech Góralski

doi:10.21697/im.2018.29.1.05

Published: 2018-01-15

Vol. 29 No. 1 (2018)

Lack the sufficient use of reason (can. 1095 n. 1 CIC), grave defect of discretion of judgment (can. 1095 n. 2 CIC), force or fear (can. 1103 CIC), simulation of matrimonial consent (can. 1101 § 2 CIC) by a man in a case brought to judgment by the son of

Wojciech Góralski

Ius Matrimoniale

Section: Orzecznictwo sądowe

https://doi.org/10.21697/im.2018.29.1.05

Abstract

On July, 28 2015 a (negative) sentence was passed in the Tribunal of the Roman Rota – in the second instance – in a case brought to judgment by an inheritor (a son) of the late Edward R. with respect to as many as four issues: insufficient use of reason (can. 1095, n. 1) by the complainant and/or a grave defect of discretion of judgment (can. 1095, n. 2) of the same person, force or grave fear (can. 1103), and/or simulation of marriage consent (can. 1101 §) by Edward. The special circumstances in the case included: conclusion of marriage by Edward when he was seriously ill, during his stay in a hospital, as well as a strong opposition of the complainant to his father’s marriage (the sentence of the Roman Rota was a preliminary in relation to the case brought to judgment in a state court concerning the succession of Edward’s estate). The rotal turnus c. Erlebach upheld the negative sentence of the first instance (in case of all issues), showing admirable insight.

Keywords:

sentence c. Erlebach of 28 July 2015, marriage, nullity of marriage, grounds for nullity of marriage, sentence

Download files

pdf (Język Polski)

Citation rules

Góralski, W. (2018). Lack the sufficient use of reason (can. 1095 n. 1 CIC), grave defect of discretion of judgment (can. 1095 n. 2 CIC), force or fear (can. 1103 CIC), simulation of matrimonial consent (can. 1101 § 2 CIC) by a man in a case brought to judgment by the son of . Ius Matrimoniale, 29(1), 83–108. https://doi.org/10.21697/im.2018.29.1.05

Cited by / Share

Wojciech Góralski

Affiliation:

Wydział Prawa Kanonicznego UKSW Poland

Bio Statement (e.g., department and rank)

Ks. prof. zw. dr hab. Wojciech Góralski – założyciel i redaktor naczelny kwartalnika ,,Ius Matrimoniale”, wiceprzewodniczący Stowarzyszenia Kanonistów Polskich, konsultor Roty Rzymskiej, sędzia w Sądzie Biskupim w Płocku.