The Holocaust and Hiroshima. Moral otherness and moral failure in war

Rolf Zimmermann

doi:10.21697/2017.53.3.07

Opublikowane: 2019-03-28

Tom 53 Nr 3 (2017)

The Holocaust and Hiroshima. Moral otherness and moral failure in war

Rolf Zimmermann

Studia Philosophiae Christianae

Dział: Artykuły naukowe

https://doi.org/10.21697/2017.53.3.07

Abstrakt

The 20th century was an age of extremes. In this article I concentrate on two disasters, the Holocaust and Hiroshima, in order to develop a philosophical reading of moral extremes under circumstances of war. My aim is to differentiate between these two events by exposing a normative framework. The significance of the Holocaust points to the phaenomenon of a rupture of species, which stands for a moral transgression never thought of. In analytical terms, this confronts us with the clashing of two normative orders: Firstly, the universal moral respect of every human being; secondly, the radical particularism of Nazism. To denounce the moral otherness of the latter is to highlight the war aims of Nazism: imperial aggression to dominate Europe, and annihilation of the Jews as a world-historical mission. In view of both aims, war against Nazism was just. The moral disaster of Hiroshima, however, stands in marked contrast to this characterization. The political leaders of the US did not intend to annihilate the Japanese people; they thought they would end war by making use of a nuclear weapon. It is, therefore, a misleading metaphor to speak of a “nuclear holocaust”, or to allude to a genocidal action in this case. This does not mean at all that dropping the bomb was justified. Quite contrary to the US official stance, it is important to consider this event in moral terms by relying on precise historical circumstances and well-founded critical analysis. There is strong evidence that it was a moral failure to opt for the bomb. This comes close to the diagnosis of a war crime within a just war framework. Nevertheless, this diagnosis must be kept distinct from the type of crime involved in the Holocaust.

Słowa kluczowe:

Holocaust, Hiroshima, moral otherness, war crime, political responsibility

Pobierz pliki

PDF (English)

Zasady cytowania

Zimmermann, R. (2019). The Holocaust and Hiroshima. Moral otherness and moral failure in war. Studia Philosophiae Christianae, 53(3), 127–148. https://doi.org/10.21697/2017.53.3.07

Cited by / Share

Bibliografia

Alperovitz G., Atomic Diplomacy: Hiroshima and Potsdam. The Use of the Atomic Bomb and the American Confrontation with Soviet Power, revised ed., Pluto Press, London/Boulder, Colorado 1985.
Google Scholar

Arendt H., Eichmann in Jerusalem: A Report on the Banality of Evil, Penguin Books, New York 1994.
Google Scholar

Bauer Y., Einige Überlegungen zur Shoah, Zeitschrift für Geschichtswissenschaft 54(2006)6.
Google Scholar

Bess M., Choices under Fire. Moral Dimensions of World War II, Knopf, New York 2006.
Google Scholar

Bialas W., Moralische Ordnungen des Nationalsozialismus, Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, Göttingen 2014.
Google Scholar

Clendinnen I., Reading the Holocaust, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 1999.
Google Scholar

DeGroot G.J., The Bomb. A Life, Harvard University Press, Cambridge/Mass. 2005.
Google Scholar

Fackenheim E.L., To Mend the World. Foundations of Future Jewish Thought, Schocken, New York 1982.
Google Scholar

Friedländer S., Nazi Germany and the Jews, Vol. I: The Years of Persecution 1933–1939, HarperCollins Publishers, New York 1997.
Google Scholar

Friedländer S., Nazi Germany and the Jews, Vol. II: The Years of Extermination, HarperCollins Publishers, New York 2007.
Google Scholar

Grayling A.C., Among the Dead Cities. Was the Allied Bombing of Civilians in WW II a Necessity or a Crime?, Bloomsbury, London 2006.
Google Scholar

Haas P.J., Morality after Auschwitz. The Radical Challenge of the Nazi Ethic, Fortress Press, Philadelphia 1988.
Google Scholar

Hasegawa T., Racing the Enemy. Stalin, Truman, and the surrender of Japan, Harvard University Press, Cambridge/Mass./London 2005.
Google Scholar

Hitler A., Mein Kampf, Zentralverlag der NSDAP, München 1937.
Google Scholar

Hiroshima in History and Memory, ed. M.J. Hogan, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge/New York 1996.
Google Scholar

Kokutai No Hongi. Cardinal Principles of the National Entity of Japan, Harvard University Press, Cambridge/Mass 1949.
Google Scholar

Koonz C., The Nazi Conscience, Belknap , Cambridge/MA, London 2003.
Google Scholar

Longerich P., Heinrich Himmler: A Life, Oxford University Press, Oxford 2011.
Google Scholar

Margalit A., Motzkin G., The Uniqueness of the Holocaust, Philosophy & Public Affairs 25(1995)1, 65–83.
Google Scholar

Minear R. H., Atomic Holocaust, Nazi Holocaust: Some Reflections, Diplomatic History 19(1995), 347–365.
Google Scholar

Rawls J., Fifty Years after Hiroshima, in: J. Rawls, Collected Papers, Harvard University Press, Cambridge/Mass. 1999, 565–572.
Google Scholar

Rorty R., Contingency, Irony, and Solidarity, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 1989.
Google Scholar

Rorty R., Truth and Progress, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 1998.
Google Scholar

Segel B. W., A Lie and a Libel. The History of the Protocols of the Elders of Zion, ed. by R.S. Levy, University of Nebraska Press, Lincoln 1995.
Google Scholar

Snyder T., Bloodlands. Europe between Hitler and Stalin, Basic Books, New York 2010.
Google Scholar

The New York Times 8(1946)19.
Google Scholar

Tych F., Speech before the German parliament on January, 27, 2010, http://www.bundestag.de/kulturundgeschichte/geschichte/tych/rede/248106.
Google Scholar

Walker J.S., Recent Literature on Truman’s Atomic Bomb Decision: A Search for Middle Ground, Diplomatic History 29(2005), 311–334.
Google Scholar

Walzer M., Just and Unjust Wars, Basic Books, London 1977.
Google Scholar

Wegner B., The Waffen-SS. Its Ideology, Organization and Function, Blackwell, Oxford 1990.
Google Scholar

Zimmermann R., National Socialism – Bolshevism – Universalism, in: Nazi Ideology and Ethics, eds. W. Bialas, L. Fritze, Cambridge Scholars Publishing, Cambridge 2014, 391–422.
Google Scholar

Zimmermann R., Philosophie nach Auschwitz, Rowohlt, Reinbek bei Hamburg 2005.
Google Scholar