(Post-)Deuteronomistic Prohibition of Transvestitism (Deut 22:5)? The Question of Its Actual Meaning and Motivations

Janusz Lemański

doi:10.21697/ct.2020.90.5.07

Published: 2021-03-29

Vol. 90 No. 5 (2020)

(Post-)Deuteronomistic Prohibition of Transvestitism (Deut 22:5)? The Question of Its Actual Meaning and Motivations

Janusz Lemański

Collectanea Theologica

Section: Articles

https://doi.org/10.21697/ct.2020.90.5.07

Abstract

Deut 22:5 marks the single instance of a prohibition of transvestitism in the Bible, and in its whole cultural milieu. The context in which it is situated suggests that it may have been inserted there as an addition, after the Babylonian captivity. That helps to narrow down the range of speculations as to the original Sitz im Leben of the law, and enables us to read it most of all within the canonical framework of the entirety of the Pentateuch. Hence, the precept pertains mainly to the principle of division of the human nature into the two sexes (Gen 1–2), the principle of retaining the order of creation (by not mixing kinds; Lev 19:19; Deut 22:9–11), and of keeping the procreational power, referred to here predominantly to masculinity (Gen 5:1–3; cf. Gen 1:28; 9:1.7).

Keywords:

transvestitism, masculinity, Book of Deuteronomy, sex, gender, procreation

Most read articles by the same author(s)

Janusz Lemański, Abraham versus Jacob , Collectanea Theologica: Vol. 88 No. 4 (2018)
Janusz Lemański, (Post-)Deuteronomic Prohibition of Transvestitism (Deut 22:5)? The Question of Its Proper Meaning and Motivations , Collectanea Theologica: Vol. 90 No. 1 (2020)
Janusz Lemański, Jephthah and his vow (Jdg 11:29-40) - A Contextual Reading , Collectanea Theologica: Vol. 90 No. 4 (2020)
Janusz Lemański, Hezekiah and the Centralization of Worship (2 Kgs 18:4.22) , Collectanea Theologica: Vol. 92 No. 1 (2022)
Janusz Lemański, Attitudes to Suicide in the Statements of Biblical Authors and Their Narrative and Cultural Context , Collectanea Theologica: Vol. 94 No. 1 (2024)
Janusz Lemański, "You Shall Not Give up a Slave to His Master…” (Deut 23:16–17): The Law That Preceded Its Epoch? , Collectanea Theologica: Vol. 92 No. 3 (2022)
Janusz Lemański, Abraham versus Jacob , Collectanea Theologica: Vol. 90 No. 5 (2020): Fasciculus specialis

Download files

PDF

Citation rules

Lemański, J. (2021). (Post-)Deuteronomistic Prohibition of Transvestitism (Deut 22:5)? The Question of Its Actual Meaning and Motivations. Collectanea Theologica, 90(5), 123–151. https://doi.org/10.21697/ct.2020.90.5.07

Cited by / Share

References

Janusz Lemański, “(Post-)deuteronomistyczny zakaz transwestytyzmu (Pwt 22,5)? Pytanie o jego właściwy sens i motywację,” Collectanea Theologica 90 (2020) no. 1: 77–104.
Google Scholar

Ancient Near Eastern Texts Relating to the Old Testament, ed. J.B. Pritchard (Princeton: University Press 3 1969) (= ANET3).
Google Scholar

Attridge H.W., Oden R.A., The Syrian Goddess (De Dea Syria). Attributed to Lucian (Society of Biblical Literature. Texts and Translations 9) (Missoula: Scholars 1976).
Google Scholar

Beyse K.M., „kelî”, in TDOT, vol. 7 (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans 1995) 169–75.
Google Scholar

Biddle M.E., Deuteronomy (Macon: Smith&Helwys 2003).
Google Scholar

Bratsioti N.P., „’îš”, in Theological Dictionary of the Old Testament, vol. 1 (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans 1977) 222-235 (= TDOT).
Google Scholar

Braulik G., Deuteronomium II 16,18-34,12 (NEB) (Würzburg: Echter Verlag 1992).
Google Scholar

Brettler M. Zvi, „Gender in the Bible”, in Jewish Study Bible, eds. A. Berlin, M. Zvi Brettler (New York: Oxford University Press 2014) 2177–84.
Google Scholar

Brettler M. Zvi, „Happy is the man, who fills his quiver with them” (Ps 127,5): Construction of Masculinities in the Psalms”, in Being a Man: Negotiating Ancient Constructs of Masculinity, ed. I. Zsolnay (Studies in the History of the Ancient Near East) (London: Routledge 2017) 198-203.
Google Scholar

Carmichael C.M., The Law of Deuteronomy (Ithaca: Cornell University Press 1974).
Google Scholar

Christensen D.L., Deuteronomy 21,10-34,12 (WBC 6B) (Nashville: Thomas Nelson Publishing 2002).
Google Scholar

Craigie P.C., The Book of Deuteronomy (NICOT) (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans 1976).
Google Scholar

Crouch C.L., The Making of Israel: Cultural Diversity in the Southern Levant (Leiden, Boston: Brill 2014). DOI: https://doi.org/10.1163/9789004274693
Google Scholar

The Dictionary of Classical Hebrew, vol. 1–8, ed. D.J.A. Clines (Sheffield: Academic Press 1993- 2011) = DCH.
Google Scholar

Doerfler M.E., „Coming Apart at the Seams: Cross-dressing Masculinity, and the Social Body in Late Antiquity”, in Dressing Judeans and Christians in Antiquity, eds. A. Batten, C. Daniel-Hughes, K. Upson-Saia (Burlington: VT: Ashgate 2014) 37–54.
Google Scholar

Drijvers H.J.W., „Atargatis”, in Dictionary of Deities and Demons in the Bible, ed. K. van der Toorn et al. (Leiden, Boston, Köln: Brill 1999)114–6.
Google Scholar

Driver S.R., A Critical and Exegetical Commentary on Deuteronomy (ICC) (Edinburg: T&T Clark 1895).
Google Scholar

Flavius Josephus, Jewish Antiquities, translated by H. St. J. Thackeray (The Loeb Classical Library) (London: Harvard University Press 1930; reprint 1961). DOI: https://doi.org/10.4159/DLCL.josephus-jewish_antiquities.1930
Google Scholar

Fox N.S., „Gender Transformation and Transgression: Contextualizing the Prohibition of Cross-Dressing in Deuteronomy 22:5”, in Mishneh Todah. Studies in Deuteronomy and Its Cultural Environment. Fs. J. H. Tigay, eds. N.S. Fox, D.A. Glatt-Gilad, M.J. Williams (Winona Lake: Eisenbrauns 2009) 49–71. DOI: https://doi.org/10.5325/j.ctv1bxgzpp.11
Google Scholar

Frymer-Kensky T., „Law and Philosophy: The Case of Sex in the Bible”, Semeia 45 (1989) :89–102.
Google Scholar

Gaster Th.H., Myth, Legend, and Custom in the Old Testament (New York: Harper & Row 1969).
Google Scholar

Gesenius Hebräisches und aramäisches Handwörterbuch über das Alte Testament, eds. R. Meyer, H. Donner, vol. 1-7 (Berlin: Springer Verlag 1987-2012) (= Ges18). DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-61713-3_1
Google Scholar

Goldingay J., Old Testament Theology. Vol. 3: Israel’s Life (Dovners Grove: IPV Academic 2009).
Google Scholar

Gordon C.H., „A Note on the Tenth Commandment”, Journal of Bible and Religion 31 (1963): 208–9. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/jaarel/XXXI.2.208
Google Scholar

A Greek – English Lexicon of the Septuagint, vol. 1–2, red. J. Lust, E. Eynikel, K. Hauspie, (Stuttgart: Deutsche Bibelgesellschaft 1996).
Google Scholar

Groneberg B., „Die sumerisch-akkadische Inanna/Ištar: Hermaphroditas?”, Die Welt des Orients 17 (1986): 25–46.
Google Scholar

Hallo W.W., „Biblical Abomination and Sumerian Taboos”, The Jewish Quarterly Review 76 (1985-1986): 21–40. DOI: https://doi.org/10.2307/1454539
Google Scholar

Hamilton V.P., „gebîrâ”, in NIDOTTE, vol. 1 (London: Paternoster Press 1997), 800–2.
Google Scholar

Harland P. J., „Menswear and Womenswear: A Study of Deuteronomy 22:5”, Expository Times 110 (1998–1999): 73–6. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/001452469811000303
Google Scholar

Harris R., „Inanna-Istar as Paradox and a Coincidence of Opposites” History of Religion 30 (1991) 261–78 = in Gender and Aging in Mesopotamia: The Gilgamesh Epic and Other Ancient Literature, ed. R. Harris (Norman: University of Oklahoma Press 2000) 158–71.
Google Scholar

Helck W., Betrachtungen zur großen Göttin und der ihn verbundenen Gottheiten (Religion und Kultur der alten Mittelmeerwelt in Parallelforschungen 2) (München, Wien: Oldenbourg 1971).
Google Scholar

Hölscher G., „Komposition und Ursprung des Deuteronomiums”, Zeitschrift für die alttestamentliche Wissenschaft 40 (1922): 161–225. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/zatw.1922.40.1.161
Google Scholar

Hoffner H.A.Jr., „Symbols for Masculinity and Femininity: Their Use in Ancient Near Eastern Pathetic Magic Rituals”, Journal of Biblical Literature 85 (1966): 326–34. DOI: https://doi.org/10.2307/3264246
Google Scholar

Houtman C., „Another Look at Forbidden Mixtures”, Vetus Testamentum 34 (1984): 226–8. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1163/156853384X00548
Google Scholar

Kaufman S.A., „The Structure of the Deuteronomic Law”, Maarav 12 (1978-1979): 105–58.
Google Scholar

Kletter R., „Pots and Polities: Material Remains of Late Iron Age Judah in Relation to Its Political Border”, Bulletin of the American Schools of Oriental Research 34 (1999): 19–54, 381–5. DOI: https://doi.org/10.2307/1357450
Google Scholar

Koehler L., Baumgartner W., Hebräisches und Aramäisches Lexikon zum Alten Testament, vol. I-II (Leiden, New York, Köln: Brill 1995) = KBL.
Google Scholar

Kosmala H., „gabar”, in Theological Dictionary of the Old Testament, vol. 2 (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans 1977) 367–82.
Google Scholar

Lambert W.G., Babylonian Wisdom Literature (Oxford: Clarendon 1960).
Google Scholar

Lemański J., Księga Rodzaju rozdziały 1-11 (NKB. ST I/1) (Częstochowa: Św. Paweł 2013).
Google Scholar

Lemański J., Księga Rodzaju rozdziały 11,27-36,43 (NKB. ST I/1) (Częstochowa: Św. Paweł 2014).
Google Scholar

Licht H., Sexual Life in Ancient Greece, transl. J.H. Freese (London: Constable 1994; German original from 1931).
Google Scholar

Liebman T., The Jewish Exegetical History of Deuteronomy 22:5: Required Gender Separation or Prohibited Cross-Dressing? (Master’s Thesis; Montreal: Department of Jewish Studies, McGill University 2002).
Google Scholar

Lipka H., „The Prohibition of Cross-Dressing. What does Deuteronomy 22: 5 Prohibit and Why?,” thetorach.com (access 10.06.2019).
Google Scholar

Loeb Classical Library, loebclassics.com.
Google Scholar

Lundbom J.R., Deuteronomy. A Commentary (Cambridge: Eerdmans 2013).
Google Scholar

Łach S., Księga Powtórzonego Prawa (PŚST II-3) (Poznań, Warszawa: Pallottinum 1971).
Google Scholar

Mayes A.D.H., Deuteronomy (NCBC) (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans 1979; 21981).
Google Scholar

Merrill E.H., Deuteronomy (NAC 4) (Nashville: B&H Publishing Group 1994).
Google Scholar

Miller P.D., Deuteronomy (Louisville: John Knox 1990) 162.
Google Scholar

Nelson R.D., Deuteronomy (OTL) (Louisville, London: John Knox Press 2002).
Google Scholar

Nielsen E., Deuteronomium (HAT 1/6) (Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck 1995).
Google Scholar

Otto E., Deuteronomium 12,1-23,15 (HThKAT) (Freiburg, Basel, Wien: Herder 2016).
Google Scholar

Paganini S., Deuteronomium (I libri Biblici. Primo Testamento) (Milano: Paoline 2011).
Google Scholar

Penna A., Deuteronomio (Torino, Roma: Manetti 1976).
Google Scholar

The Works of Philo: Complete and Unabridged, translated by Charles Duke Yonge 1854–1857, online version: earlyjewishwritings.com/philo.html.
Google Scholar

Pryke L.M., Ishtar: Gods and Heroes of Ancient World (London, New York: Routledge 2017). DOI: https://doi.org/10.4324/9781315716329
Google Scholar

Rad G. von, Deuteronomio, transl. A dal Bianco (Brescia: Paidea Editrice 1979; German original from 1964).
Google Scholar

Rad G. von, Teologia Starego Testamentu, transl. B. Widła (Warszawa: Pax 1986).
Google Scholar

Rodd C.S., Glimpses of a Strange Land. Studies in Old Testament Ethics (Edinburg: T&T Clark 2001).
Google Scholar

Römer W.H.Ph., „Randbemerkungen zur Travestie von Deut. 22.5”, in Travestie in the World of the Old Testament (Studia Semitica Neerlandica 16), red. M. Heerm van Voss i inni (Assen: Van Gorcum 1974), 217–22. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1163/9789004354531_026
Google Scholar

Rofé A., „The Arrangement of the Laws in Deuteronomy”, in Deuteronomy. Issues and Interpretation (London, New York: T&T Clark 2002) 55–77.
Google Scholar

Roscoe W., „Priest of the Goddess: Gender Transgression in Ancient Religion”, History of Religion 35 (1996): 213–7. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1086/463425
Google Scholar

Slawik J., Slawik I., „Homoseksualizm problemem Kościoła?”, Rocznik Teologiczny 52 (2010): 9–69.
Google Scholar

Słownik grecko-polski, ed. O. Jurewicz (Warszawa: Wydawnictwo Szkolne PWN 2001).
Google Scholar

Słownik mitologii Mezopotamii, eds. J. Black, A. Green (Katowice: Księżnica 1998).
Google Scholar

Steuernagel C., Das Deuteronomium übersetzt und erklärt (HK I 3/1) (Göttingen: Vandenhoeck& Ruprecht 21923).
Google Scholar

Tigay J.H., Deuteronomy (JPS Torah Commentary) (Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society 1996).
Google Scholar

Tronina A., „Eposy ugaryckie o Kerecie i Akhacie”, in Scripturae Lumen. Biblia i jej oddziaływanie, vol. 1: Ewangelia o Królestwie, ed. A. Paciorek (Lublin: Wydawnictwo KUL 2009), 563–621.
Google Scholar

Vedeler H.T., „Reconstructing Meaning in Deuteronomy 22:5: Gender, Society, and Transvestitism in Israel and the Ancient Near East”, Journal of Biblical Literature 127 (2008): 459–76. DOI: https://doi.org/10.2307/25610133
Google Scholar

Walton J.H., The Lost World of the Torah: Law as Covenant in Ancient Context (Downer Grove: IVP Academic 2019).
Google Scholar

Weinfeld M., Deuteronomy and Deuteronomic School (Oxford: Clarendon 1972).
Google Scholar

Weippert H., „Kleidung”, in Biblische Reallexikon, ed. K. Galling (HAT Erste Reihe 1) (Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck 1977), 185–8.
Google Scholar

Weippert H., „Kleidung”, in Neues Bibel-Lexikon, vol. 2, eds. M. Görg, B. Lang (Zürich, Düsseldorf: Benziger 1995) 495-499.
Google Scholar

Wenham G. J., „The Old Testament Attitude to Homosexuality”, Expository Times 102 (1990–1991): 259–363. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/001452469110201203
Google Scholar