The problem of respect in environmental philosophy

Barbora Baďurová

doi:10.21697/seb.2016.14.2.05

Published: 2016-06-30

Vol. 14 No. 2 (2016)

The problem of respect in environmental philosophy

Barbora Baďurová

Studia Ecologiae et Bioethicae

Section: Humanistic Foundations of Environmental Protection

https://doi.org/10.21697/seb.2016.14.2.05

Abstract

The term respect is frequently used in ordinary communication however it also has a significant role in philosophical discussions focused on environmental ethics. This essay deals with the ambiguity of the term respect. The author analyzes respect from a philosophical point of view claiming that several possible interpretations of what the word respect means and what standards of behavior to which it is to be related. It is pointed out that the issue of whether respect should be understood as an attitude or behavior. The author highlights the problem of constraints imposed by respect and the relation of respect to intrinsic and instrumental value. The approach is analyzed also from the point of view of Kant’s ethics, nevertheless the author examines it also from the standpoints of various contemporary environmental ethicists (e.g. Taylor, Goodpaster, Katz, Lo). However, author concludes that understanding respect as a virtue appears to be a most promising approach in contemporary environmental ethics because it can solve the problem of finding balanced interpretation of respect.

Keywords:

respect, respect for life, intrinsic value, environmental ethics

Download files

pdf

Citation rules

Baďurová, B. (2016). The problem of respect in environmental philosophy. Studia Ecologiae Et Bioethicae, 14(2), 77–89. https://doi.org/10.21697/seb.2016.14.2.05

Cited by / Share

References

Bradley B., 2006, Two concepts of intrinsic value, ethical theory and moral practice, Vol 9, 111-30.
Google Scholar

Callicott J. B., 1986, The Search for an environmental ethic, in: Beauchamp T. L., Regan T. (eds.) “Matters of life and death. Mc Graw- Hill”, New York, 299-335.
Google Scholar

Claude Evans J., 2005, With respect for nature, State University Of New York Press, New York.
Google Scholar

Davion V., 2006, Itch scratching, patio building and pesky flies: Biocentric individualism Revised, Environmental Ethics, Vol 28, 115-128.
Google Scholar

Dillon, R. S. Respect, <http://Plato.Stanford.Edu/Entries/Respect/#Phiworchiresre/Con>, date of access: 20.10. 2007.
Google Scholar

Dzwonkowska D., 2013, Virtue and vice in environmental discourse, Studia Ecologiae et Bioethicae, Vol 11, 61-76.
Google Scholar

Goodpaster K., 1978, On being morally considerable, Journal of Philosophy, Vol 75, 308-325.
Google Scholar

Katz E., 1997, Nature as subject, Rowman and Littlefield, Lanham.
Google Scholar

Kawall J., 2003, Reverence for life as a viable environmental virtue, Environmental Ethics, Vol. 25, 339-358.
Google Scholar

Koricheva J., Siipi H., 2004, The phenomenon of biodiversity, in: Oksanen M., Pietarinen J. (eds) “Philosophy and biodiversity”. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Google Scholar

Korsgaard C., 1983, Two distinctions in goodness, The Philosophical Review, Vol 92, 169-195.
Google Scholar

Lee K., 2003, The source and locus of intrinsic value, in: Light, A. (eds.) “Environmental Ethics”, Wiley-Blackwell, New York.
Google Scholar

Lo Y.-S., 1999, Natural and artifactual: Restored nature as subject, Environmental Ethics, Vol. 21, 247-266.
Google Scholar

McShane K., 2007, Why environmental ethics shouldn´t give up on intrinsic value, Environmental Ethics, Vol. 29, 43-61.
Google Scholar

O´Neill J., 1992, Varieties of intrinsic value, Monist, Vol 75, 119-137.
Google Scholar

Regan T. 1992, Does environmental ethics rest on a mistake?, Monist, Vol 75, 161-182.
Google Scholar

Sandler R., 2007, Character and environment, Columbia university press, New York.
Google Scholar

Sandler R., Cafaro P. (eds.) 2005, Environmental virtue ethics, Rowman and Littlefield, Oxford.
Google Scholar

Siipi H., 2011, Is neuro-enhancement unnatural and does it morally matter?, Trames, Vol 15, 188–203.
Google Scholar

Taylor P. W., 1986, Respect for nature, Princeton University Press, Princeton.
Google Scholar