FORM AND SUBSTANCE OF LEGAL CONTINUITY

Rafał Mańko

doi:10.21697/zp.2017.17.2.10

Pubblicato il: 2018-01-10

V. 17 N. 2 (2017)

FORM AND SUBSTANCE OF LEGAL CONTINUITY

Rafał Mańko

Zeszyty Prawnicze

Sezione: Artykuły

https://doi.org/10.21697/zp.2017.17.2.10

Abstract

The distinction between form and substance (content), which is derived from philosophy, plays a significant role in contemporary scientific legal discourse. Therefore, it seems important to confront the phenomena of legal continuity with the various understandings of the form vs. substance distinction, found in scientific legal discourse. The analysis is justified by the fact that in scientific legal discourse the indication that a certain form of reasoning is ‘formalist’ or that a certain phenomenon is ‘simply formal’ but not ‘substantive’ has a strong evaluative aspect. In his earlier works the author of the article has proposed, by referring inter alia to the works of K. Renner and h. Collins, to use the concept of ‘legal survivals’ in order to conceptualise the phenomenon of legal continuity ocurring in the case of continued existence of concrete and determined legal institutions, despite a change of the political and economic system, accompanied often by the change of socio-economic function of those surviving legal institutions. This allows to formulate a research question as to whether legal survivals are of a ‘formal’ or ‘substantive’ nature. Referring to four distinct ways of understanding the form vs. substance dichotomy in contempoary scientific legal discourse, the present paper replies to the research question by indicating in which sense of the distinction can legal continuity be described as ‘formal’, and in which as ‘substantive’.

Scarica file

PDF (English)

Regole di citazione

Mańko, R. (2018). FORM AND SUBSTANCE OF LEGAL CONTINUITY. Zeszyty Prawnicze, 17(2), 207–234. https://doi.org/10.21697/zp.2017.17.2.10

##plugins.themes.libcom.share##

Riferimenti bibliografici

Althusser, L. For Marx, London-New York 2005
Google Scholar

Atiyah, P.S., Summers, R. Form and Substance in Anglo-American Law, Oxford 1987, p. 23
Google Scholar

Balbus, I.D. Commodity Form and Legal Form: An Essay on the “Relative Autonomy” of the Law, «Law and Society» 11/1977
Google Scholar

Berger, P., Luckmann, T. Social Construction of Reality: A Treatise in the Sociology of Knowledge, London 1991 [1966]
Google Scholar

Bogucka, I. Funkcje prawa. Analiza pojęcia [The Functions of Law: An Analysis of the Concept], Kraków 2000
Google Scholar

Collins, h. Marxism and Law, Oxford-New 1988
Google Scholar

Cserne, P. Formalism in Judicial Reasoning: Is Central and Eastern Europe a Special Case? [in:] Central European Judges under the European Influence: The Transformative Power of the EU Revisited, ed. M. Bobek, Oxford 2015
Google Scholar

Dajczak, W. Doświadczenie prawa rzymskiego a pojęcie dobrej wiary w europejskiej dyrektywie o klauzulach niedozwolonych w umowach konsumenckich, «Zeszyty Prawnicze» 1/2001
Google Scholar

Del Mar, M. review of: R. Summers, Form and Function of a Legal System, Cambridge 2006, «Cambridge Law Journal» 65.3/2006
Google Scholar

Galligan, D., Matczak, M. Formalism in Post-communist Courts. Empirical Study on Judicial Discretion in Polish Administrative Courts Deciding Business Cases [in:] Judicial Reforms in Central and Eastern European Countries, ed. R. Coman, Bruges 2007
Google Scholar

Giaro, T. Roman Law Always Dies With a Codification, [in:] Roman Law and European Legal Culture, ed. A. Dębiński, M. Jońca, Lublin 2008
Google Scholar

Giaro, T. Legal Tradition of Eastern Europe. Its Rise and Demise, «Comparative Law Review» 2.1/2011
Google Scholar

Gray, T.C. Judicial Review and Legal Pragmatism, «Wake Forest Law Review» 38/2003
Google Scholar

Grochowski, M. Uchwały Sądu Najwyższego a jednolitość orzecznictwa. Droga do autopojetyczności systemu prawa? [Supreme Court Resolutions and the Uniformity of Case-Law: Road Towards the Legal System’s Autopoiesis?], [in:] Jednolitość orzecznictwa. Standard – instrumenty – praktyka [Uniformity of Case-Law: Standard, Instruments, Practice], ed. M. Grochowski et al., Warszawa 2015
Google Scholar

hesselink, M.W. The New European Legal Culture, Deventer 2001
Google Scholar

Kennedy, D. Form and Substance in Private Law Adjudication, «Harvard Law Review» 89/1976
Google Scholar

Kozak, A. Myślenie analityczne w nauce prawa i praktyce prawniczej [Analytical Thinking in Legal Science and Legal Practice], Wrocław 2010
Google Scholar

Kühn, Z. The Judiciary in Central and Eastern Europe: Mechanical Jurisprudence in Transition?, Leiden-Boston 2011
Google Scholar

Longchamps de Bérier, F. Podstawienie powiernicze, Kwartalnik Prawa Prywatnego 8.2/1999
Google Scholar

Longchamps de Bérier, F. Skargi edylów kurulnych a dyrektywa 1999/44/EC Parlamentu Europejskiego i Rady w sprawie określonych aspektów sprzedaży i gwarancji na dobra konsumpcyjne, «Studia Iuridica» 44/2005
Google Scholar

Łętowska, E. Kilka uwag o praktyce wykładni [Some Remarks on the Practice of Interpretation] «Kwartalnik Prawa Prywatnego» 11.1/2002
Google Scholar

Malinowski, B. A Scientific Theory of Culture and Other Essays, New York 1961
Google Scholar

Mańko, R. Sądowe Sądowe stosowanie ‘Corpus Iuris Civilis’ w Afryce Południowej w świetle wybranego orzecznictwa [The Judicial Application of the ‘Corpus Iuris Civilis’ in South Africa in the Light of Selected Case-Law], «Zeszyty Prawnicze» 4.3/2004
Google Scholar

Mańko R., Is the Socialist Legal Tradition ‘Dead and Buried’? The Continuity of Certain Elements of Socialist Legal Culture in Polish Civil Procedure, [in:] Private Law and the Many Cultures of Europe, ed. T. Wilhelmsson, Alphen aan den Rijn 2007, p. 92-94
Google Scholar

Mańko R., The Unification of Private Law in Europe from the Perspective of Polish Legal Culture, «Yearbook of Polish European Studies» 11/2008-2009
Google Scholar

Mańko, R. Quality of Legislation Following a Transition from Really Existing Socialism to Capitalism: A Case Study of General Clauses in Polish Private Law, [in:] The Quality of Legal Acts and Its Importance in Contemporary Legal Space, ed. J. Rozenfelds et al., Rīga 2012
Google Scholar

Mańko, R. Survival of the Socialist Legal Tradition? A Polish Perspective, «Comparative Law Review» 4.2/2013
Google Scholar

Mańko, R. Weeds in the Gardens of Justice? The Survival of Hyperpositivism in Polish Legal Culture as a Symptom/«Sinthome», «Pólemos: Journal of Law, Culture and Literature» 7.2/2013
Google Scholar

Mańko, R. The Cooperative Member’s Proprietary Right to an Apartment: A Legal Survival of the Period of Actually Existing Socialism on Polish Private Law, «Zeszyty Prawnicze» 15.4/2015
Google Scholar

Mańko, R.‘We Do Not Recognise Anything “Private”’: Public Interest and Private Law Under the Socialist Legal Tradition and Beyond, [in:] Private Interest and Public Interest in European Legal Tradition, ed. B. Sitek et al., Olsztyn 2015
Google Scholar

Mańko, R. Relikty w kulturze prawnej – uwagi metodologiczne na tle pozostałości epoki socjalizmu realnego w polskim prawie prywatnym [Survivals in Legal Culture: Methodological Remarks Against the Background of Remnants of the Period of Actually Existing Socialism in Polish Private Law], «Przegląd Prawa i Administracji» 102/2015
Google Scholar

Mańko, R., Legal Survivals: A Conceptual Tool for Analysing Post-Transformation Continuity of Legal Culture, [in:] Tiesību efektivitāte postmodernā sabiedrībā, ed. J. Rozenfelds et al., Rīga 2015
Google Scholar

Mańko, R. Use of Extra-Legal Arguments in the Judicial Interpretation of European Contract Law: A Case Study on Aziz v Catalunyacaixa (CJEU, 14 March 2013, Case C-415/11), «Law and Forensic Science» 10.2/2015
Google Scholar

Mańko, R., Transformacja ustrojowa a ciągłość instytucji prawnych – uwagi teoretyczne [Systemic Transformation and the Continuity of Legal Institutions: Theoretical Remarks], «Zeszyty Prawnicze» 16.2/2016
Google Scholar

Matczak, M. ‘Summa iniuria’. O błędzie formalizmu w stosowaniu prawa [‘Summa iniuria’: The Formalist Error in Applying the Law], Warszawa 2007
Google Scholar

Mączyński, A. Dawne i nowe instytucje polskiego prawa mieszkaniowego [New and Old Institutions of Polish housing Law], «Kwartalnik Prawa Prywatnego» 11.1/2002
Google Scholar

Milej, T. Europejska kultura prawna a kraje Europy Środkowej i Wschodniej [European Legal Culture and Central Eastern European Countries], «Przegląd Legislacyjny» 15.1/2008
Google Scholar

Niemi, M.I. Form and Substance in Legal Reasoning: Two Conceptions, «Ratio Juris» 23.4/2010
Google Scholar

Pashukanis, E.B. Law and Marxism: A General Theory. Towards a Critique of the Fundamental Juridical Concepts, transl. by B. Einhorn, London 1983 [1929]
Google Scholar

Pilich, M. Zasady współżycia społecznego, dobre obyczaje czy dobra wiara? Dylematy nowelizacji klauzul generalnych prawa cywilnego w perspektywie europejskiej [Principles of Social Community Life, Good Customs or Good Faith? Dillemas of Amending the General Clauses of Civil Law in a European Perspective] [in:] Europeizacja prawa prywatnego [The Europeanisation of Private Law], ed. M. Pazdan et al., II, Warszawa 2008
Google Scholar

Płeszka, K., Gizbert-Studnicki, T. Dwa ujęcia wykładni prawa. Próba konfrontacji [Two Approaches to Legal Interpretation: An Attempt at their Confrontation], «Zeszyty Naukowe Uniwersytetu Jagiellońskiego» 677/1984
Google Scholar

Redelbach, A., Wronkowska, S., Ziembiński, Zarys teorii państwa i prawa [An Outline of the Theory of State and Law], Warszawa 1994
Google Scholar

Reich, N. Transformation of Contract Law and Civil Justice in the New EU Member Countries, «Penn State International Law Review» 23/2005
Google Scholar

Renner, K. The Institutions of Private Law and Their Social Functions, translated by A. Schwarzschild, London-Boston 1976
Google Scholar

Sacco, R. Legal Formants: A Dynamic Approach to Comparative Law (Instalment I of II), «American Journal of Comparative Law» 39.1/1991
Google Scholar

Sacco, R., Legal Formants: A Dynamic Approach to Comparative Law (Instalment II of II), «American Journal of Comparative Law» 39.2/1991
Google Scholar

Sitek, B. Stosowanie edyktu «de nautis, cauponibus et stabulariis» w systemie prawa Republiki Południowej Afryki, «Zeszyty Naukowe Uniwersytetu Szczecińskiego» 274 «Roczniki Prawnicze» 11/1999
Google Scholar

Soper, P. On the Relation between Form and Substance in Law, «Ratio Juris» 20.1/2007
Google Scholar

Stawarska-Rippel, A. O klauzulach generalnych w pierwszych latach Polski Ludowej słów kilka [A Few Words on the General Clauses in the First Years of People’s Poland], «Miscellanea Iuridica» 6/2005
Google Scholar

Stawarska-Rippel, A. O politycznych założeniach procedury cywilnej w Polsce Ludowej [On the Political Foundations of the Civil Procedure in People’s Poland], «Miscellanea Iuridica» 7/2005
Google Scholar

Stelmachowski, A. Kontraktacja [The Cultivation Contract], [in:] System prawa prywatnego [The System of Private Law], VII: Prawo zobowiązań – część szczegołowa2 [Law of Obligations: General Part], ed. J. Rajski, Warszawa 2004.
Google Scholar

Summers, R. Form and Function in a Legal System [2006], Cambridge 2009
Google Scholar

Uzelac, A. Survival of the Third Legal Tradition?, «Supreme Court Review» 49/2010
Google Scholar

Wołodkiewicz, W. I cambiamenti del codice civile polacco dopo 1989 possono essere trattati come segno del ritorno alla tradizione romanistica?’, [in:] The Roman Law Tradition in Societies in Transition, ed. P. Bělovský, M. Skřejpek, Praha 2003
Google Scholar

Wróblewski, J. Sądowe stosowanie prawa [The Judicial Application of Law], Warszawa 1988
Google Scholar

Zawadzka, Z. Pozycja procesowa prokuratora w postępowaniu cywilnym [The Procedural Position of the Prosecutor in Civil Proceedings], «Prokuratura i Prawo» 6/2010
Google Scholar

Zieliński, T.J. Prawne ramy ekspresji religijnej w amerykańskich uniwersytetach publicznych [The Legal Framework for Religious Expression in American Public Universities], «Studia z Prawa Wyznaniowego» 11/2008
Google Scholar

Zomerski, W. Conference Report: 1st International Conference of the Central European Network of Legal Scholars (CENELS) On «25 Years After the Transformation: Law and Legal Culture in Central and Eastern Europe. Between Continuity and Discontinuity», Masaryk University, Brno, Czech Republic, 16–17 April 2015, «Wrocław Review of Law, Administration and Economics» 4.2/2014 [2015].
Google Scholar